Culprit

I think this is who has been stealing my tomatoes by the branch! Below, you can see her on the outside of the fence, innocently munching on a weed. Look through the hanging farm, where you can see the Christmas lights I put up yesterday to ward off deer--too late, of course. She's to the left of the leftmost shepherd's hook.

Next, she's in my yard. She spent some time there, then hopped the next fence into the neighbor's. But, their dogs spooked her and she came back for a while. Just watching me.
I guess five tomatoes isn't too bad a price!